P&G drew the most interest in PR circles with these claims because having an effective apples for pears measurement tool-box is something that the industry has striven for over the past decade with only a modicum of success. This study looked at the launch of six different products, the return was better in four cases. There is a lot of qualifying statements in the article quote.
In addition critics such as Tom Formeski argue (try here and the comments here) that the return on investment for smaller brands is not so impressive. And to build a big brand, a healthy dose of conventional marketing communications helps enormously.
Don’t drink the Kool-Aid
Dorothy Crenshaw, president of Stanton Crenshaw, an independent PR firm based in New York, says that many of her colleagues are suffering from ‘consultant envy’,but that PR remains a very inexact science. There are also limits to the miracles it can be expected to achieve. She claims to have turned down a $1m commission from a client desperate to boost his business-to-business website in the midst of the dotcom boom because he had nothing much to tell the world. Sometimes a PR firm can indeed shape or create a buzz about a product, but not always. For PR to work, she says, “you have to have a legitimate story.”
- Spending on PR in America reached some $3.7 billion in 2005 (source: Veronis Suhler Stevenson)
- Forecast growth in PR spend 9% a year (source: Veronis Suhler Stevenson)
- Forcecast for the overall US market for advertising and marketing, now worth a colossal $475 billion and growing at 6.7% a year
This growth rate is still below the magic 10 per cent that venture capitalists would look for in a business.
- The PR industry there employs 48,000 people (source: Centre for Economics and Business Research)
- 80% were working ‘in-house’, for companies or other organisations
- Just over half of Britain’s in-house PRs work for the public sector, health organisations and charities.
- These organisations are also the biggest users of PR consultancies
On traditional PR
Which is why agencies and inhouse PR staff are looking to expand into website design and participation media including blogging, leaving comments on other people’s blogs, pod casts etc. In the longer-term this subversion of participation media may kill the goose that is laying the golden eggs in the same way that the advertising industry is now struggling to get cut through.
- Celebrity / entertainment